Skip to content
SmartUpdate

Concerned Regarding His Artificial Intelligence Reliance: Is It Affecting Critical Thinking?

My boyfriend for a significant period is 44 years old. He manages his own venture and has ADHD. While he has historically found mundane tasks difficult, the advent of generative AI has revolutionized his productivity. Now, however, I'm becoming concerned that he appears incapable to do many things without relying on an AI.

He is a heavy user of a well-known AI chatbot, employing it even when more accurate non-AI alternatives exist. For example, he might query the AI for rail information instead of using a purpose-built travel app, notwithstanding the latter being more reliable. A recent personalized review placed him in the highest tier of users worldwide.

The Heart Anxieties

My key worry focuses on his capacity for independent thought. I also think about the broader environmental impact of such pervasive technology use. I fully acknowledge it's a useful tool for his professional life, but its application has spread to cover nearly every facet of his everyday life.

I am painfully aware that I might come across critical, and I understand his ADHD can foster obsessive behaviors. I am seeking advice on how to approach this complex topic with him compassionately.

Expert Perspectives

Running a business is inherently stressful. While ADHD is a consideration, it's worth questioning whether underlying anxiety might be at play, with AI use acting as a response rather than the primary issue.

"It's possible we're on the verge of a new diagnostic category of 'chatbot overdependence syndrome' as we head into an age of growing reliance on AI," suggested one clinical psychologist. "When used appropriately, AI aids us, but overdependence could have negative consequences."

The expert continued, noting that for someone with ADHD—who may experience a limited attention span, trouble focusing, and reduced planning skills—AI can be a "perfect fit." This makes it extremely helpful, but also raises the propensity of becoming excessively reliant on it.

Another advocate framed it as a potential "support tool" for someone who might be having difficulties. "AI can lead you into a spiral," they said, "but it can also help you and assist in organizing your thoughts, scheduling tasks, and achieving goals."

Where Application Becomes Excessive Reliance

In this case, the use seems to exceed practical support. It can reflect a form of eroding confidence, which is insidious. The psychologist observed: "Difficulties arise when your use of AI goes beyond resolving the immediate issue. It begins to feel like a bond has developed, and you imbue it with human qualities—a manifestation of our own needs for validation."

A Path Ahead

You are wise to avoid constant criticism, which often rarely addresses anything and simply becomes background noise. As with any sensitive conversation, select your time carefully, when you are both relaxed.

One recommended approach is to inquire with openness: 'Tell me what are you getting out of it? What makes is this tool such a big deal for you, and which needs is it bridging?' Then, collaboratively, you can consider whether there are alternative solutions or more balanced ways to use the technology.

The psychologist noted that, "as with any dependency syndrome, the first step is recognition that there is a concern. It's easy to become judgmental of the person in difficulty, but that may only prompt them to retreat further into reliance. The case must be made compassionately, understanding that being without the crutch of the AI probably feels like a threat."

A Positive Perspective

The good news is that, unlike a cohort growing up with AI as a constant, your boyfriend has a established track record of managing well without it. Hopefully, he can be helped to recall of that ability and find a healthy place where AI enhances the strengths he already possesses. The underlying anxiety, however, likely needs to be explored for you both to find resolution.

The writer

Matthew Moore

A tech journalist with over a decade of experience covering software trends and digital transformation.

SmartUpdate

Type to search articles.